Return-Path: Received: from leslie.mystery.com ([198.202.235.7]) by mailin00.sul.t-online.de with smtp id 12JU5E-05LLvsc; Sat, 12 Feb 2000 05:23:00 +0100 Received: (qmail 22489 invoked from network); 12 Feb 2000 04:26:42 -0000 Received: from angus.mystery.com (root@198.202.235.1) by leslie.mystery.com with SMTP; 12 Feb 2000 04:26:42 -0000 Received: from localhost (daemon@localhost) by angus.mystery.com (8.9.3/8.9.3) with SMTP id XAA25901; Fri, 11 Feb 2000 23:17:41 -0500 Received: by angus.mystery.com (bulk_mailer v1.12); Fri, 11 Feb 2000 23:16:44 -0500 Received: (from majordomo@localhost) by angus.mystery.com (8.9.3/8.9.3) id XAA25833 for crsenglish-outgoing; Fri, 11 Feb 2000 23:13:00 -0500 Received: from mailhost1.dircon.co.uk (mailhost1.dircon.co.uk [194.112.32.65]) by angus.mystery.com (8.9.3/8.9.3) with ESMTP id XAA25830 for ; Fri, 11 Feb 2000 23:12:53 -0500 Received: from london_srv.iwpr.net (iwpr.dircon.co.uk [194.112.45.32]) by mailhost1.dircon.co.uk (8.9.1/8.8.7) with ESMTP id EAA03032 for ; Sat, 12 Feb 2000 04:12:47 GMT Received: by LONDON_SRV with Internet Mail Service (5.5.2448.0) id ; Sat, 12 Feb 2000 04:13:59 -0000 Message-ID: <218581ACEC23D31184CD0008C7333E7F1CA5D4@LONDON_SRV> From: Institute for War & Peace Reporting To: Institute for War & Peace Reporting Subject: IWPR'S CAUCASUS REPORTING SERVICE, NO. 18 Date: Sat, 12 Feb 2000 04:13:58 -0000 MIME-Version: 1.0 X-Mailer: Internet Mail Service (5.5.2448.0) Content-Type: text/plain; charset="iso-8859-1" X-Spam-Envelope: relay_access X-Spam-Header: received 4 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit X-MIME-Autoconverted: from quoted-printable to 8bit by angus.mystery.com id XAA25831 Sender: owner-crsenglish@angus.mystery.com Reply-To: Institute for War & Peace Reporting X-Loop: Majordomo @ NSTS Precedence: bulk WELCOME TO IWPR'S CAUCASUS REPORTING SERVICE, NO. 18, February 11, 2000. MOSCOW TARGETS MOUNTAIN STRONGHOLDS. Russia carpet-bombs the Chechen mountains in a bid to flush out rebel troops. But the separatists say the only victims of the raids are unarmed civilians. Ruslan Isaev in Nazran reports. CHECHEN 'SPIRITS' HAUNT RUSSIANS. The Russian army's propaganda machine is misfiring as Chechens leaders it claims to have killed rise from their graves. Ruslan Isaev in Nazran counts the living. A SENTRY'S TALE. Federal troops take pity on a Russian woman searching desperately for her missing fiancé. Erik Batuev in Chechnya reports. CLASH OF THE TBLISI TITANS. Georgia's political heavyweights are set to cross swords in the wake of Shevardnadze's expected election victory. Ia Antadze in Tblisi follows the rivals. TURKEY EASES ARMENIA BLOCKADE. Economic hardship has prompted Turkey to ease its blockade of neighbouring Armenia. Artem Yerkanian in Yerevan reports. AZERBAIJAN'S U-TURN ON CENSORSHIP. Increasing attacks on the independent media raise concerns of a official effort by the authorities in Baku to silence their critics. Shakhin Rzayev in Baku reports. ********** VISIT IWPR ON-LINE: www.iwpr.net ************** MOSCOW TARGETS MOUNTAIN STRONGHOLDS Russia carpet-bombs the Chechen mountains in a bid to flush out rebel troops. But the separatists say the only victims of the raids are unarmed civilians. By Ruslan Isaev in Nazran Russian aircraft continued to pound mountain villages to the south of Grozny this week, despite Chechen claims that they had already been abandoned by separatist forces. Rebel leaders said that Su-24 bombers had staged dozens of sorties over Itum-Kale and Shatoy, strategic heights near the Georgian border, blasting the settlements with vacuum bombs and napalm. Seventy civilians were reported to have died in the attacks between February 6-9. Itum-Kale was seized on Thursday by Russian paratroops dropped from helicopter gunships - a victory which the Russian high command has hailed as the final stage in its seizure of the Argun Gorge. However, Chechen commander Aslambek Abdulkhadzhiev said rebel guerrillas had left the village several days previously, heading for remote mountain strongholds to the east and west. Airborne units captured nothing more than "deserted heaps of rubble", he said. In an earlier incident, Russian bombers blitzed Katyr-Yurt and Shaami-Yurt with 1.5-tonne bombs, deployed for the first time in the campaign. Federal troops surrounded the villages after 600 guerrillas under Ruslan Gelaev were reported to be regrouping there. After nearly a week of ground-to-ground rocket bombardments, the civilian populations of Katyr-Yurt and Shaami-Yurt left the settlement under a white flag to negotiate a ceasefire with Russian commanders. One local elder who gave his name as Shamil said the rebels had left the village the previous evening, moving on to mountain strongholds. Shamil claimed that many of the civilians fell under a mortar barrage while others were fired on by Russian troops. Soon, the streets were littered with corpses which residents were too terrified to bury. Russian troops entered the village on February 8 and embarked on an orgy of looting, said Shamil, burning down the plundered houses in a bid to cover their tracks. The federal press-centre subsequently announced that 300 Chechen fighters were killed in the fighting around Katyr-Yurt - but it has often succumbed to the temptation to exaggerate rebel losses in the past. The bombing raids came as an ominous prelude to the "last phase of the anti-terrorist campaign in Chechnya" as federal troops attempt to seize the Argun and Vedeno gorges, two vital passes into the rocky hinterland. General Victor Kazantsev, commander of the Russian forces, said February 9, "We know where the bandit groups are congregating. First and foremost, they will be destroyed there. The fate of the bandits has already been decided." Fired by their surprise victory in Grozny, federal forces have been swift to follow up their advantage, mounting up to 200 bombing raids a day over the mountain passes. It is thought there are between 5,000 and 7,000 separatists still at large. While Moscow trumpeted its victory along the Argun River, paratroops were dropped on Day, Khidi-Khutor and Tsa-Vedeno, key positions on the high ground south-east of Grozny. Serzhen-Yurt, at the mouth of the Vedeno Gorge, was reportedly seized by elite Russian marines on Thursday night. But despite a new confidence amongst the Russian general staff, occupying forces are facing constant harassment in territories already under their control. In the wake of the Grozny siege, rebel fighters are apparently melting back into the civilian population, waiting for opportunities to launch partisan attacks on federal strongholds. Last week, two gun emplacements in Urus-Martan and Achkhoy-Martan were fired on by rebel snipers while, four kilometres outside Argun, guerrillas destroyed a stretch of railway track, then strafed two military trains with rocket-propelled grenades and machine-gun fire. Federal retaliation has been brutal. Refugees heading for the Ingushetian border tell horrifying tales of Russian terror tactics while Chechen leaders claim 600 civilians have been shot by federal troops since the retreat from the capital. New York-based Human Rights Watch says it is investigating around 50 reports of summary executions. Seda Saralapova, from the Michurina district of Grozny, said she had seen 20 people shot in the courtyard of a local hospital. Saralapova had been hiding in a debris-choked shell-hole at the time. She said the civilians - including two 10-year-old girls, Zoya Sultanova and Malika Serbieva - were executed after Russian troops had looted and burned their homes. Dismissing out of hand any accusations that war crimes have been committed in Chechnya, Russia's generals are taking tougher measures to assert federal control over occupied villages. Forces have been redeployed across the republic: a division has been based at Khankala, in Grozny's western suburbs, while motor-rifle regiments of between 2,500 and 3,000 men will be stationed at Shali and Itum-Kale by the end of March. Around 50 fortified checkpoints have been set up along the main highways into Grozny while 30 kilometres of mountain roads have been mined. On Thursday, the rebels' underground TV station, Kavkaz, was discovered by federal agents in the village of Oktyabrskoe near the Dagestani border and shut down. Rebels who surrendered during the retreat from Grozny - 5,000 according to General Kazantsev, 500 according to Justice Minister Yuri Chaika - have been dispatched to detention camps. More than 230 have reportedly been released. Yuri Biryukov, of the Russian prosecutor's office said most of the prisoners were captured after the February 1 government amnesty had expired. "If the Duma extends the amnesty, then we'll reconsider this question [of setting them free]," he said. Ruslan Isaev, a freelance Chechen reporter, is a regular IWPR contributor. CHECHEN 'SPIRITS' HAUNT RUSSIANS The Russian army's propaganda machine is misfiring as Chechens leaders it claims to have killed rise from their graves. By Ruslan Isaev in Nazran As Russia's war machine shifts its focus to Chechnya's southern mountains, its propaganda machine is homing in on the rebel high command. Realising that cohesion within the rebel forces relies largely on the charisma of individual commanders, Moscow has been devoting considerable efforts to killing them off - if only on paper. The trouble is the "spirits" - the federal army's nickname for the Chechens -have a habit of coming back to haunt the wishful-thinking Russian generals. Vice-President Vakha Arsanov, declared dead by the federal press centre on February 1, rose from the grave a week later to declare, "Rumours of my death are greatly exaggerated" in an interview on the underground Chechen TV station, Kavkaz. Ruslan Gelaev, who was on the official casualty list after the fall of Grozny, reappeared on February 2 to organise the defence of Katyr-Yurt where a large rebel force was surrounded by Russian troops and pounded by artillery. Aslambek Ismailov, commander of the Grozny defence garrison, was resurrected by the Russians on February 7 when he was named as one of the field commanders who took part in the exchange of Radio Liberty reporter Andrei Babitsky for two Russian PoWs. Chechen sources had reported that Ismailov died in Alkhan-Kala during the retreat from the shattered capital. It was, in fact, after the Alkhan-Kala bloodbath that the Russian generals started counting heads. It is thought that a force of 2,000 rebels blundered into a minefield near the village as they attempted to break out of Grozny on January 31. With unusual candour, the Chechen high command announced that three top commanders died in the fiasco: Grozny Mayor Lecha Dudaev, Aslambek Ismailov and Khunkar-Pasha Israpilov. The Russian media added that maverick warlord Shamil Basaev had lost both legs and his right eye. They eventually settled for the heel of his right foot. Meanwhile, General Victor Kazantsev, commander of the Russian forces in Chechnya, declared that the Chechen high command had been effectively destroyed and "a number of ring-leaders are currently in captivity". Kazantsev refused to name any of his high-ranking prisoners, although they are thought to include Chechen health minister Umar Khambiev, who was chief surgeon at Grozny's Hospital No. 9 throughout the Russian siege. However, despite the bold assertions of the Russian generals, federal agents have reportedly been exhuming the corpses of dozens of rebel fighters in a bid to check their facts. It is thought the bodies were removed by Russian army lorries in the dead of night so that experts from the Federal Security Service could later establish their identities and amend their Most Wanted list. Villagers in Alkhan-Kala report that around 10 corpses were dug up in the first days of February, including the body of Lecha Dudaev, nephew of Chechnya's first president, Dzhokhar Dudaev. Similar incidents have been reported in the Michurina and Zavodskoy districts of Grozny. Hopes that the feared warlord Emir Khattab might be among the casualties were dashed when the Jordanian-born militant appeared on Chechen TV to announce his plans to defend rebel mountain strongholds. Declared dead on two occasions by the Russian general staff, Khattab continues to inspire his followers by a reputation for invulnerability. By turning humble mortals into living legends, the Russian propaganda machine may be doing the embattled military far more harm than good. Ruslan Isaev, a freelance Chechen reporter, is a regular IWPR contributor A SENTRY'S TALE Federal troops take pity on a Russian woman searching desperately for her missing fiancé. By Erik Batuev in Chechnya The sentry gaped in astonishment. A young woman was making her way towards the bunker, weaving deftly between the trip wires, which criss-crossed the road. In the half-light of the early morning, her movements seemed practised and deliberate. The paratrooper had every reason to be jittery. Several days before, his unit had approached a group of Chechens near the town of Gudermes. The men had raised their hands in surrender, waited for the soldiers to come near. Then, on a prearranged signal, they pulled hand grenades out of their pockets and bowled them towards the enemy. To his growing discomfort, the sentry noticed that the woman was clutching her hands to her chest, as if carrying a heavy object. He turned to his comrades in alarm, yelling that a Chechen kamikaze was launching a surprise attack. The snipers rushed to the gun emplacements and trained their weapons on the intruder. "Halt, who goes there?" The woman stopped in her tracks, gripping her coat with a fierce intensity. "Hands up!" The paratrooper's voice cracked with tension. The woman raised her hands and smiled - apparently, there was nothing concealed inside her coat. The soldiers looked at each other in bewilderment, then the sergeant asked for a volunteer to search her. A corporal ventured out and walked up to the woman. The snipers stared fiercely through their telescopic sights. She didn't flinch as the man searched her pockets. "She's clean!" he called out with barely concealed relief. The woman kept smiling. After the tension had subsided, the soldiers warmed to their unexpected guest. They gave her a cup of tea, asked her how she came to be there. The woman told them that she was a Russian and her fiancé, a federal soldier, had gone missing in action during the first Chechen war. She had been searching for him for nearly four years, clinging to the hope that he might somehow have survived. In the beginning, she had pursued one clue after another, eagerly seizing at rumours that he was a prisoner, a hostage or a fugitive from the military authorities. She took charity, lived like a vagrant. Once she fell into the hands of Chechen guerrillas. They held her in a cellar for nearly a week and treated her like a slave. Then they sold her on to another gang and the woman gradually lost her grip on reality. Now she smiles too much and wanders through the Russian military positions, in search of a ghost. The paratroopers kept her in their bunker for a while, said she was one of "their own" because her fiancé had been soldier. Then they handed her on to the military police, who said she was insane and sent her to Mozdok. The paratroopers quickly forgot about the woman - she was a tiny speck in a vast river of human suffering which swept past them every day. Erik Batuev is a journalist with Svet newspaper in Nazran CLASH OF THE TBLISI TITANS Georgia's political heavyweights are set to cross swords in the wake of Shevardnadze's expected election victory By Ia Antadze in Tblisi A fierce power struggle is brewing in Georgia between the leading lights of the ruling cabal. Serving President Eduard Shevardnadze's victory in elections scheduled for April 9 appears to be a foregone conclusion, but the battle to succeed him will then begin in earnest. An intense rivalry is already emerging among the three main contenders in Shevardnadze's ruling Citizen's Union party, which mopped up nearly two-thirds of the seats in last year's parliamentary elections, effectively pushing all other political factions out of the picture. But the three gladiators, Parliamentary Chairman Zurab Zhvania, Minister of State Vaja Lordkipanidze and Niko Lekishvili, leader of the parliamentary majority, are expected to step up their fight for popular support, increased parliamentary influence and, last but not least, the approval of President Shevardnadze after he is re-elected. They will also be struggling to discredit one another wherever possible and score political points. The most immediate prize is the post of prime-minister, proposed 18 months ago as part of a package of constitutional reforms. It is likely the post will be introduced after the April elections and whomever Shevardnadze appoints will be seen as his heir apparent in 2005. Lekishvili is a former entrepreneur who enjoys the respect of the local business community. In the last elections, he succeeded in bringing a large body of his supporters into parliament and now wields considerable influence over the republic's top financiers. While Lekishvili lacks the power base to launch his own leadership bid, he may choose to throw his weight behind either of his rivals and this could seriously tilt the balance of power in the Georgian government. Zurab Zhvania has been working hard to portray himself as a bastion of honesty. He is a champion of free speech, national culture and nongovernmental groups. However, his reputation has been tarnished by his apparent inability to shake up the Georgian legal system, which is dogged by corruption and in-fighting. Many voters are also concerned that the ranks of the Citizen's Union party - hand-picked by Zhvania - includes several controversial figures who are opposed to legislative reforms. Formerly Georgia's ambassador to Moscow, Vaja Lordkipanidze was recalled by Shevardnadze in August 1998 and appointed Minister of State. He has since been given the hottest political potatoes to juggle: Abkhazia and the national economy. These unenviable tasks offer Lordkipanidze opportunities both for covering himself in political glory and for committing political suicide. The Georgian refugees who fled Abkhazia during the conflict are pinning their hopes on Lordkipanidze - and will be slow to forgive him if he fails. The challenge of turning round the Georgian economy is no less demanding. According to the state department of statistics, 90 per cent of the population live below the poverty line while 30 per cent are thought to exist on the edge of starvation. The average salary in Georgia is around 70 lari ($35) a month whilst the minimum required for a normal existence is estimated at between 113 and 190 lari. Vaja Lordkipanidze is well aware that his rivals are eagerly awaiting his downfall. Zurab Zhvania misses no opportunity to highlight the failure of economic reforms and has applauded recent moves by Shevardnadze to increase Lordkipanidze's responsibilities. Give the minister of state enough rope, reasons Zhvania, and he will hang himself. But Lordkipanidze himself is cautious, rarely entering into open conflict and keeping his personal spheres of interest tightly under wraps. He knows that Zhvania will have to start tackling major national problems if he is to gain credibility within the party and the country as a whole. Shevardnadze will have to time his appointment of a prime minister carefully. Too soon and the candidate will be unlikely to last the distance; too late and he will have no time to gain the public's confidence. Certainly, the population at large will look at the president's official heir with intense scrutiny. While they credit Shevardnadze with building the Georgian state, they no longer expect him to spearhead the radical reforms needed to drag the fledgling republic onto the international stage. Ia Antadze is a journalist on the Tbilisi newspaper Kavkasioni. TURKEY EASES ARMENIA BLOCKADE Economic hardship has prompted Turkey to ease its blockade of neighbouring Armenia. By Artem Yerkanian in Yerevan The stretch of railway from the Turkish town of Kars to the Armenian border is rusty. The last train crossed the frontier in 1993, when the Turkish authorities, under heavy pressure from the US government, agreed to send its neighbour urgent humanitarian aid. The Turkish authorities closed the border as a gesture of support for Azerbaijan in its conflict with Armenia over Nagorno-Karabakh, an Armenian-populated enclave in Azerbaijan. But Armenians learned to live under the Turkish blockade, and one imposed by Azerbaijan, finding new trading routes through Iran and the seaports of Georgia. Now, however, Turkey is keen to improve relations with Armenia and the reopening of the border is high of the agenda. Not least because the Turkish provinces close to the Armenian border, in particular Kars and Erzrum, are less economically developed than the rest of the country. Local experts say that social problems and unemployment are a major reason for emigration from Kars to central Turkey, currently running at 8,000 people per year. The government is concerned the depopulation could eventually lead to local Kurds outnumbering Turks. Many Turks there hope the opening of the border will boost the regional economy. "Isolation damages both sides, " says the mayor of Kars, Naib Alibeioghlu. " The present situation favours Georgia and Iran, who are making big profits by serving as intermediaries between the Turkish and Armenian businessmen". Businessmen, it seems, are not waiting for the government to give them the green light to deal with Armenia. They have already struck an agreement to trade directly on the Turkish-Georgian border. "Our goods arrive in Armenia through third countries, " said the President of the Chamber of Commerce and Industry in Trabzon, a Turkish city. "The lifting of the border blockade will be great for our country. It will improve the situation in the eastern part of the Black Sea, and open new markets for Turkey." Meanwhile, diplomatic efforts to lift the blockade are being stepped up. The late prime minister of Armenia, Vazgen Sarkisian, called on Washington last September to press the Turkish authorities to end Yerevan's isolation. And Armenian President Robert Kocharian declared in November that the problem would be solved in near future, following talks with his Turkish counterpart, Suleiman Demirel. In another sign of improving relations between the two countries, Gumir in Armenia and Kars have declared themselves sister cities. And, increasingly, more and more Turkish firms are doing business directly with Armenia, without recourse to third countries. Five or six companies involved in trade, tourism and transportation are now based in Yerevan. There is a whole network of shops in the Armenian border town of Gumir belonging to a businessman from Turkey. Gradually, Armenian manufacturers are entering into the Turkish market too. Everything from cheese, raw leather and benches are finding their way across the border. "Companies rebuilding towns in north-eastern Turkey damaged by the recent earthquake need inexpensive, but quality cement," said spokesman for the Armenian Ministry of Foreign Affairs ministry, Ara Papian. "The Turks can easily purchase it in Armenia." The volume of informal trade between Turkey and Armenia totals approximately $120 million per year. Roads and railways will allow both countries to make significant profits from transit. Experts believe that, once the border is opened, the figure could increase tenfold. Artem Yerkanian is deputy editor-in-chief of Novoe Vremya ("New Times") newspaper in Yerevan AZERBAIJAN'S U-TURN ON CENSORSHIP Increasing attacks on the independent media raise concerns of a official effort by the authorities in Baku to silence their critics. By Shakhin Rzayev in Baku The offices of Azerbaijan's biggest selling opposition newspaper were stormed this week by government supporters and one of its journalists arrested in the latest crackdown on the country's independent media. The raid on Eni Musavet and the detention of Elbai Gasanly, who was later released, comes four months after the independent broadcaster, Sara, was forced off the air. [See "The Silencing of Sara TV," by Shahin Rzayev, Caucasus Reporting Service No. 5, 4-Nov-99] The episode suggests that the authorities are seeking roll back press freedoms, despite the repeal of a presidential decree on censorship two years ago. Local analysts believe the government is being encouraged by muted international reaction to Sara's closure. In the latest incident, around 100 people from the town of Nekhram of the Nakhichevan Autonomous Republic demonstrated on February 7 in front of the Eni Musavat's offices. The protest was sparked by series of articles by one of the paper's reporters, Albai Gasanly, which had been highly critical of Nakhichevan's leading official, Vasif Talybov, and suggested that the residents of Nekhram - the home town of President Geider Aliev - enjoyed a privileged life. The protesters attempted to storm the newspaper office, brushing past police, but were held back by barricades assembled by the journalists. "We'd never seen our police behaving so meekly before," said one journalist inside the building. Eni Musavat sells almost three times as many copies as its largest rival and generally reflects the views of the opposition Musavat Party, which is headed by Isa Gambar, the former speaker of the Azerbaijan parliament. Several hours before the attack on Eni Musavat's offices, Gasanly was arrested and flown to Nakhichevan, where he was sentenced to 15 days in prison. Other people interviewed in his controversial articles were also arrested. Independent newspapers subsequently published prominent photographs of Gasanly and demanded his release. He was freed a day after their appeal. The chairman of the Musavat Party, Isa Gambar said that he considered Gasanly's arrest an act of revenge against the journalist and an attempt to scare the free press. Ex-president Abulfaz Elchibei described the raid on the newspaper as "government terror" and alleged that "Geidar Aliev knew about the action, and that supporters of his brother, Dzhalal Aliev, took a direct part in it." The leader of the Azerbaijani Social Democrat Party, Zardusht Alizade, said the president's family is a taboo subject. Indeed, last summer, a journalist with the Bakinsky Boulevard newspaper, Irada Guseinova, was sentenced to a year in prison for calling Dzhalal "King of the Petrol Pumps". Talybov, the subject of Gasanly's investigation, is married to Aliev's niece. Aliev has yet to respond to the incidents but his adviser Ali Gasanov said, "The inhabitants of Nekhram were upset by the publications in the Eni Musavat newspaper and expressed their unhappiness. That is their constitutional right, though the method of protest was poorly chosen." The view was echoed by Dzhalal Aliev who condemned the Musavat Party as a fascist organisation and described the attacks on the newspaper as an "appropriate reaction" by Azeri citizens. Shahin Rzayev is IWPR Project Editor in Baku. ********** VISIT IWPR ON-LINE: www.iwpr.net ************** IWPR's Caucasus Reporting Service provides the regional and international community with unique insiders' perspective on the Caucasus. Using our network of local journalists, the service publishes objective news and analysis from across the region upon a weekly basis. The service forms part of IWPR's Caucasus Project based in Tbilisi and London which supports local media development while encouraging better local and international understanding of a conflicted yet emerging region. IWPR's Caucasus Reporting Service is supported by the UK National Lottery Charities Board. The service is currently available on the Web in English and will shortly be available in Russian. All IWPR's reporting services including Balkan Crisis Reports and Tribunal Update are available free of charge via e-mail subscription or direct from the Web. The institute will be launching a fourth news service, IWPR Central Asia Reports, in the coming months. To subscribe to any of our existing or forthcoming news services, e-mail IWPR Programmes Officer Duncan Furey at duncan@iwpr.net. For further details on this project and other information services and media programmes, visit IWPR's Website: . Editor-in-chief: Anthony Borden. Managing Editor: Yigal Chazan; Assistant Editor: Alan Davis. Commissioning Editors: Giorgi Topouria in Tbilisi, Shahin Rzayev in Baku, Mark Grigorian in Yerevan, Michael Randall and Saule Mukhametrakhimova in London. Editorial Assistance: Felix Corley and Heather Milner. To comment on this service, contact IWPR's Programme Director: Alan Davis alan@iwpr.net The Institute for War & Peace Reporting (IWPR) is a London-based independent non-profit organisation supporting regional media and democratic change. Lancaster House, 33 Islington High Street, London N1 9LH, United Kingdom.Tel: (44 171) 713 7130; Fax: (44 171) 713 7140. E-mail: info@iwpr.net; Web: www.iwpr.net The opinions expressed in IWPR's Caucasus Reporting Service are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of the publication or of IWPR. Copyright (c) IWPR 2000 IWPR'S CAUCASUS REPORTING SERVICE, NO. 18 -- ### -- {#} ----------------------------------------------------+[ crsenglish ]+---